WHY NEGLECT THE DIFFICULT?
Records of eastern birds in the West, especially in California, show an ever-increasing taxonomic discrepancy. Reports of especially distinctive species, resembling no local birds, may increase at a nearly geometric rate: there were already 382 valid California occurrences of the American Redstart (Setophaga ruticilla) through 1968 alone (McCaskie 1970a:42), and over 200 of the less conspicuous Blackpoll Warbler (Dendroica striata; McCaskie 1970b:95), which had not even been authentically recorded anywhere in the West prior to the 1960s.
Yet California still lacks published records of several eastern flycatchers (mostly recorded from Arizona) and of many eastern subspecies: for example, those of Hermit and Swainson’s thrushes (as migrants; Catharus guttatus and ustulatus), Bell’s, Solitary, and Warbling vireos (Vireo belli, solitarius, and gilvus), such warblers as Nashville (“Vermivora” ruficapilla), Yellow (Dendroica petechia), and Wilson’s (Wilsonia pusilla), and various finches and sparrows—even though some of these, in the far north, extend west to Alaska. Eastern birds appear to stray west only if they lack western relatives, just as migrants used to “arrive” only on weekends!
Nevertheless, all straggling is of interest. What, then, should we be looking for?