THE UNITED STATES DISTRIBUTION OF THE CALIFORNIA BLACK-TAILED GNATCATCHER
The Black-tailed Gnatcatcher, Polioptila melanura, is represented in California by two subspecies: P. m. lucida and P. m. californica (AOU 1957). These forms were originally described as distinct species on the basis of plumage differentiation, with californica having darker underparts and less white on the underside of the rectrices than lucida (Figure 1).
Later, Grinnell (1926) concluded that individual variation exhibited by the central Baja California race pontilis and the Cape San Lucas form margaritae suggested that californica and lucida were merely the extremes in a continuous series of subspecies. However, there do not appear to be any documented localities of overlap or genetic introgression between lucida and the californica/pontilis/margaritae group (Grinnell 1928, Grinnell and Miller 1944).
Therefore, rather than indicating genetic interchange between the populations, the resemblance of margaritae to the similarly pale lucida could be interpreted as convergence resulting from a north–south cline of dark to light plumaged birds within the californica group. Also, since Grinnell's taxonomic revision was based on morphological characters and apparently failed to consider the possible significance of relatively pronounced vocalization differences between lucidaand californica, additional investigation of speciation in the Black-tailed Gnatcatcher complex is currently being conducted.